Post by 3kliksphilip on Sept 28, 2009 10:58:09 GMT
I've had a look at all of the entries, and I'm very impressed. I've seen flooded ruins, log fires, floating islands and even a rollercoaster. The judging will commence shortly, once I've cleared up a couple of problems (HL2 EP2.... but with dust 2 models?).
dont use youtube they're either people who cant talk... or 3klikphilip
Don't worry, he didn't forget. PM'ed him back on October 24th and he told me he was waiting to go through all of them with his house mate for a third opinion. I figure he is just trying to be fair and thorough so be patient. Peace.
SORRY SORRY SORRY! He's busy on COD2 at the moment.
It's so much responsibility to mark other people's efforts, when I think about how many hours must have gone into them. After my ratings my Mum rated them and I had horrible pangs of guilt as she rated some higher than I had, for stuff I didn't really think much of when I saw the map. She'd go 'Oooh what a pretty island map in the middle of the night with glowy beatles! So atmospheric!' while I'd go '...Stupid, blocky house' or something like that. But yeah. This was based on looks, so if anything my Mum is probably less biased than I am. At the end of the day, if your map is technically brilliant then I'm likely to rate you up for it, if it has nice atmosphere and creative ideas then my Mum's more likely to see it. It's less biased than one person rating everything, but it also takes a lot longer to mark.
But, here are the current results, with 3 different ratings per map based on 3 different aspects...
Bullet 7,6,7 - Me 9,8,9 - My MUM
Blackheartiii 7,5,7 - Me 8,7,8 - My MUM
Dadope 4,6,5 - Me 5,8,7 - My MUM
Dafatcat 6,8,4 - Me 3,3,4 - My MUM
Daniel Hands 6,8,7 - Me 9,10,10 - My MUM
Demaffe 2,3,2 - Me 0,1,0 - My MUM
Erik 7,8,6 - Me 8,6,7 - My MUM
Feris 8,8,9 - Me 5,7,6 - My MUM
Jammster 5,6,6 - Me 3,2,5 - My MUM
Joshtresis 6,7,5 - Me 5,6,7 - My MUM
Mabilis 4,5,4 - Me 5,6,7 - My MUM
Motanum 7,4,7 - Me 2,1,2 - My MUM
Magicone 7,6,5 - Me 6,8,7 - My MUM
Robin 10,9,9 - Me 10,,8,10 - My MUM
Rusty 9,10,10 - Me 9,8,10 - My MUM
Supermariokarter 6,7,5 - Me 6,7,7 - My MUM
Wii1mii (Aww) 4,6,5 - Me 3,3,5 - My MUM
Minisheaffy and Defultpotato, you both contained custom textures and I'm still trying to get them working.
The Volcano_complex entry came in too late (By several weeks.) However, it was also marked so you can see where it could have come. 8,9,9 - Me 7,8,7 - My MUM